| Year | Student-Athlete | Sport | Organization | Team |
| 1998 | Ludger Bain '98 | Men's Basketball | National Association of Basketball Coaches | Honorable Mention |
| 2004 | Raj Bhangoo '04 | Men's Ice Hockey | American Hockey Coaches Association | First |
| 2013 | Shaun Jameson '13 | Men's Ice Hockey | American Hockey Coaches Assciation | First |
| 2016 | Alex Potts '17 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Second |
| 2017 | Dan McSolla '18 | Men's Indoor Track & Field | US Track & Field and Cross Country Coaches Association | Eighth Place (Mile) at NCAA Championships |
| 2017 | Jake Reed '17 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | First |
| 2017 | Alex Potts '17 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Second |
| 2017 | Collin Ritter '18 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Second |
| 2017 | Sean Mullen '17 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Second |
| 2018 | Collin Ritter '18 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | First |
| 2019 | Leah Rogoz '20 | Women's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Honorable Mention |
| 2021 | Peter Klembczyk '21 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | First |
| 2021 | Ryan Love '20 M '21 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Second |
| 2021 | Anthony Krzykowski '24 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Honorable Mention |
| 2022 | Connor Adams '22 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | First |
| 2022 | Jacob LaBouliere '24 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | First |
| 2022 | Hunter Oshman '23 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Honorable Mention |
| 2023 | Jared Pierce '23 | Men's Indoor Track & Field | US Track & Field and Cross Country Coaches Association | Eighth Place (Shot Put) at NCAA Championships |
| 2023 | Hunter Oshman '23 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Second Team |
| 2023 | Jared Pierce '23 | Men's Outdoor Track & Field | US Track & Field and Cross Country Coaches Association | Eighth Place (Shot Put) at NCAA Championships |
| 2023 | Emma Sanders '27 | Women's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Honorable Mention |
| 2024 | Jacob LaBouliere '24 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | First |
| 2024 | Jacob LaBouliere '24 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coashes Association | First |
| 2024 | Brandon Dunz M'24 | Men's Volleyball | American Volleyball Coaches Association | Honorable Mention |